Bank Statement vs DSCR Loans: What’s Best for You?

If you’re a self-employed real estate investor, freelancer, or full-time landlord, qualifying for traditional financing can be tough—even when your properties are profitable.

Fortunately, non-QM loans offer two powerful solutions that sidestep the red tape of conventional underwriting: Bank Statement Loans and DSCR Loans.

Both are designed for borrowers who don’t fit the standard W-2 mold. But they serve different purposes—and choosing the right one can save you thousands and help you scale smarter.

In this guide, we’ll compare Bank Statement vs DSCR loans, so you can confidently choose the financing strategy that best fits your portfolio, cash flow, and future plans.

Quick Overview: What Are These Loans?

🔹 DSCR Loan (Debt Service Coverage Ratio)

• Used for investment properties only
  
• Approval based on the property’s rental income, not your personal income
  
• Ideal for long-term rental holds or BRRRR refis
  
• Common with LLC ownership
  

🔹 Bank Statement Loan

• Available for primary residences, second homes, or rentals
  
• Approval based on your business or personal bank deposits
  
• Ideal for self-employed buyers with inconsistent tax returns
  
• Often used when DSCR doesn’t apply or for owner-occupied homes
  

Head-to-Head Comparison

When to Use a DSCR Loan

Use a DSCR loan when:

• You’re buying or refinancing a rental property
  
• You want to close in an LLC or business entity
  
• Your property has strong cash flow
  
• You don’t want to provide personal income documentation
  
• You’re executing a BRRRR strategy
  

📌 DSCR loans are designed for investors building long-term portfolios.

When to Use a Bank Statement Loan

Use a bank statement loan when:

• You’re buying a primary home, second home, or STR
  
• Your income is strong, but your tax returns are low
  
• You’re self-employed and have steady business deposits
  
• The property doesn’t yet qualify for DSCR underwriting
  
• You want flexibility with property type and usage
  

📌 Perfect for entrepreneurs, realtors, or 1099 professionals who don’t show high AGI.

Real-World Scenarios

🏠 DSCR Example:

Alex buys a duplex for $450,000. The monthly rent is $4,000, and the P&I payment will be $3,000/month.

• DSCR = $4,000 ÷ $3,000 = 1.33
  
• He qualifies for a 75% LTV DSCR loan—no tax returns required
  

💼 Bank Statement Example:

Brianna is a full-time STR operator and earns $15,000/month in deposits but shows only $40K/year in taxable income.

• She uses 24 months of business bank statements
  
• Qualifies for a bank statement loan on a new STR property
  
• No DSCR requirement or lease needed
  

Pros & Cons

✅ DSCR Loan Pros:

• Great for cash-flowing rentals
  
• No personal income verification
  
• Scalable for portfolios
  
• Allows LLC ownership
  
• Works with BRRRR strategies
  

❌ DSCR Loan Cons:

• Only for investment properties
  
• Property must meet minimum DSCR (1.20+)
  
• Prepayment penalties common
  

✅ Bank Statement Loan Pros:

• Flexible use (primary, second home, rental)
  
• No tax returns or W-2s
  
• Ideal for business owners and self-employed
  
• Some lenders accept Airbnb/STR income
  

❌ Bank Statement Loan Cons:

• Higher rates and stricter documentation
  
• Manual underwriting of statements
  
• Expense ratios may reduce qualifying income
  

Which Loan Is Best for You?

Final Thoughts

Both DSCR and bank statement loans are designed to help self-employed investors get approved without jumping through the hoops of conventional lending.

• If you’re scaling a rental portfolio → DSCR loan
  
• If you’re self-employed with strong deposits → Bank statement loan
  

Choosing the right one depends on how you earn, how the property performs, and what you’re trying to buy.