Landlord Insurance vs. Property Manager Coverage

When you hire a property manager to oversee your rental property, it might feel like you’re off the hook for everything. But here’s the truth:

Even with a property manager, you still need landlord insurance—because their coverage doesn’t protect your investment the way yours must.

Too many investors mistakenly assume their property manager’s insurance covers everything. The reality? Property managers are insured to protect their business, not your building.

This guide explains the key differences between landlord insurance and property manager insurance, what each covers, and how to ensure your rental property is fully protected from damage, liability, and unexpected lawsuits.

What Is Landlord Insurance?

Landlord insurance, also called a dwelling policy (often DP-3), is a specialized insurance policy designed for non-owner-occupied properties that are used for rental income.

🔑 Landlord Insurance Typically Covers:

• The structure (dwelling)
  
• Detached structures (garage, shed)
  
• Loss of rental income (if property becomes uninhabitable)
  
• Liability coverage (if someone is injured on your property)
  
• Vandalism and malicious mischief
  
• Fire, wind, hail, and water damage (excluding flood unless added)
  

💡 Optional add-ons may include tenant default coverage, equipment breakdown, or rent guarantee.

What Is Property Manager Coverage?

Property managers carry their own insurance to cover the services they perform, such as collecting rent, screening tenants, and maintaining property records.

🔐 Property Manager Insurance Typically Includes:

• Errors and omissions (E&O) insurance
  
• General liability for their office or employees
  
• Workers’ compensation (if they have employees)
  
• Fidelity bonds to protect against employee theft
  
• Tenant placement liability (in case of screening errors)
  

🚫 What it does not cover: your property, your income, or your liability as the owner.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Why You Need Both

Even if your property manager is highly competent and insured, their policy doesn’t protect your physical property or your cash flow.

You need landlord insurance to:

• Cover the building itself from fire, storm, or vandalism
  
• Protect your rental income if the unit becomes unlivable
  
• Shield yourself from liability lawsuits by tenants or guests
  
• Meet lender requirements (especially for DSCR or conventional rental loans)
  

They need property manager insurance to:

• Cover mistakes in tenant placement
  
• Protect against legal claims from tenants
  
• Insure employees or contractors under their care
  

Real-World Example

Scenario: A tenant slips on the icy walkway of your rental property and sues for $80,000 in medical bills and damages.

• Your property manager’s liability insurance won’t apply—they didn’t cause the injury or fail in their duties.
  
• Your landlord insurance will defend you, cover legal fees, and pay any settlement (up to your policy limits).
  

📌 Without landlord insurance, you’d be on the hook—even if you have a property manager.

Tips for Proper Coverage

✅ 1. Always Carry Your Own Landlord Policy

Don’t rely on your property manager’s policy to protect your rental—it doesn’t.

✅ 2. Require Property Manager to Have Their Own Coverage

At a minimum, ask for:

• E&O coverage
  
• General liability
  
• Fidelity bond (for theft protection)
  

Get proof of coverage annually.

✅ 3. Add Your Property Manager as an Additional Insured

This can help streamline claims and prevent coverage gaps related to shared responsibility.

✅ 4. Confirm Coverage with Your DSCR or Rental Lender

Most lenders require:

• Dwelling coverage at full replacement cost
  
• Liability limits of $500K–$1M
  
• Proof of policy before closing
  

Final Thoughts

Landlord insurance protects your property.
Property manager insurance protects their business.

Both play a role—but only one shields your rental from disaster, liability, and lost income.If you’ve hired a property manager (or plan to), double-check that you’re covered from both sides. Because no matter who handles the day-to-day operations, you’re still the owner—and the risk is still yours.