What to Look for in a Real Estate Agent’s Track Record Before You Hire Them
2 minute read
·
June 4, 2025

Share

Your agent is one of the most important members of your investing team. But how do you know if they’re truly qualified to help you scale your portfolio—not just sell you a house?

One of the best ways to vet them is by evaluating their track record. Here’s how to do it.

1. Look at the Types of Properties They’ve Sold

Investor agents typically work with:

  • Multifamily homes (duplexes, triplexes, etc.)
  • Fixer-uppers and flips
  • Properties with STR/Airbnb potential

If their sales history is mostly retail single-family homes in luxury neighborhoods, that’s a red flag.

Find Your Ideal Investment Agent

  • Connect with agents who are also investors​
  • Get matched with local market experts
  • Tailored support for strategies like BRRRR, house hacking, and flips​
  • Leverage insights from a community of 3M+ investors

2. Ask for Deal Volume and Investor Clients

How many investment properties have they closed in the last year? Ask for:

  • Average price point
  • Property types they specialize in

An investor-friendly agent should be able to list past deals with confidence.

3. Check Their Online Presence

Review their:

  • Zillow or Realtor.com sales map
  • BiggerPockets profile activity
  • Social media posts—do they talk about investment strategy, cash flow, or BRRRR?

Look for thought leadership and investor-focused marketing.

4. Ask for Investor References

A serious agent should have a few investor clients willing to vouch for them. Ask:

  • “Can I speak with another investor you’ve helped recently?”
  • “Have you worked with clients doing BRRRR, DSCR loans, or STRs?”

Learn more about BRRRR Investing

5. Look for Personal Investing Experience

Some of the best investor agents are investors themselves. Ask:

  • “Do you own rental properties?”
  • “Have you personally done a flip, BRRRR, or short-term rental?”

It’s not a requirement—but it’s a bonus.

6. Evaluate Their Communication and Speed

Ask how they:

  • Source deals for investor clients
  • Alert you when a good deal hits the market
  • Negotiate investor-style contracts

A top agent should move quickly and bring value before, during, and after the transaction.


Want to Work With a Top-Performing Investor Agent?

We’ll connect you with a real estate agent whose track record proves they know how to help investors win.

Find a real estate agent who understands investors


Read Next:

Find Your Ideal Investment Agent

  • Connect with agents who are also investors​
  • Get matched with local market experts
  • Tailored support for strategies like BRRRR, house hacking, and flips​
  • Leverage insights from a community of 3M+ investors

Our advise is based on experience in the mortgage industry and we are dedicated to helping you achieve your goal of owning a home. We may receive compensation from partner banks when you view mortgage rates listed on our website.

Share


More on Real Estate Agents