Best Insurance Providers for Property Managers in 2025

If you’re a property manager—or a real estate investor hiring one—having the right insurance coverage is essential. From tenant disputes to maintenance mishaps, property managers face serious legal and financial risks that general liability alone won’t cover.

Whether you manage dozens of units or run a boutique firm, the right provider can protect your business, your clients’ properties, and your reputation.

In this guide, we’ll cover the top insurance providers for property managers in 2025, what types of policies they offer, and how to choose the best one for your business or your investment team.

What Kind of Insurance Do Property Managers Need?

A quality property management insurance package should include:

🔹 1. General Liability

Protects against bodily injury, property damage, and legal costs from accidents or negligence.

🔹 2. Errors & Omissions (E&O) Insurance

Covers professional mistakes—like leasing to a bad tenant or mishandling escrow funds.

🔹 3. Workers’ Compensation

If you have employees, this is legally required in most states.

🔹 4. Commercial Property Insurance

Protects your office space, equipment, and business contents.

🔹 5. Tenant Discrimination Coverage

Covers lawsuits related to Fair Housing Act violations.

🔹 6. Cyber Liability

Protects against data breaches or hacks (especially if you collect rent or manage tenant info online).

🔹 7. Fidelity Bonds / Employee Dishonesty Coverage

Covers theft by employees or contractors.

Top Insurance Providers for Property Managers (2025)

Here are the best-rated carriers and platforms offering tailored policies for professional property managers this year:

✅ 1. Steadily

Best for: Landlord and property manager bundles

• Specializes in rental property and property manager insurance
  
• Offers landlord, general liability, and PM-specific E&O policies
  
• Online quote process is fast and transparent
  
• Works well for those managing single-family and small multifamily units
  

Notable Perks:

• Supports short-term and long-term rentals
  
• Can insure multiple properties and roles under one account
  
• Easy to add property owners as additional insured
  

📌 Great choice for dual-role landlord-managers or PMs with 50 doors or less.

✅ 2. Travelers Insurance

Best for: Large property management firms

• Offers comprehensive commercial packages
  
• Includes general liability, cyber, auto, umbrella, and workers’ comp
  
• Backed by strong claims support and national reputation
  
• Preferred by PMs with corporate structures or employees
  

Notable Perks:

• Customizable risk management programs
  
• Can scale across multi-state operations
  
• Option to integrate with third-party tenant screening and financial services
  

📌 Ideal for growing firms or those handling hundreds of units.

✅ 3. Hiscox

Best for: Solo property managers or small PM teams

• Affordable E&O and general liability policies for real estate professionals
  
• Monthly payment plans available
  
• Known for quick online applications and strong small business service
  

Notable Perks:

• Available in most states
  
• Can add tenant discrimination or cyber coverage
  
• Flexible for freelancers and new PM businesses
  

📌 Best pick for startups, side-gig managers, or virtual property managers.

✅ 4. The Hartford

Best for: Full-service brokerages offering property management

• Long-standing reputation with robust commercial insurance offerings
  
• Covers both real estate sales and property management
  
• Includes errors & omissions, general liability, and property coverage
  

Notable Perks:

• Custom-built programs for real estate professionals
  
• Optional flood, auto, and business interruption insurance
  
• Partner integrations for payroll and benefits
  

📌 A strong fit for broker-owner PMs and real estate firms expanding services.

✅ 5. Proper Insurance

Best for: Property managers who handle short-term rentals (Airbnb, Vrbo)

• Industry leader in vacation rental insurance
  
• Covers both property and liability risks in one policy
  
• Underwritten by Lloyd’s of London and tailored to the STR industry
  

Notable Perks:

• Includes guest-caused damage and loss of income
  
• Optional PM liability coverage if managing multiple STRs
  
• STR-specific wording protects against local regulation issues
  

📌 Essential for PMs managing short-term rental portfolios or vacation homes.

What to Look for When Choosing a Provider

Here’s what real estate investors and property managers should evaluate:

Final Thoughts

The best insurance providers for property managers in 2025 combine comprehensive coverage, investor-grade flexibility, and responsive service.

Whether you’re managing 10 rentals or 1,000, the right insurance helps you:

• Stay legally protected
  
• Build trust with owners and tenants
  
• Sleep better knowing you’re covered if something goes wrong
  

And remember—your coverage is just as important as your contracts, vendors, or tech stack.