Compare DSCR vs. Conventional Loans: Which One’s Right for You?

When it comes to financing your next rental property, one question always comes up:

Should I go with a DSCR loan or a conventional mortgage?

The answer depends on your investment strategy, income situation, and long-term goals. While both can finance rental properties, they’re built for very different borrowers.

In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences between DSCR and conventional loans, explain the pros and cons, and help you decide which one is the better fit for your next deal.

What Is a DSCR Loan?

A DSCR loan (Debt Service Coverage Ratio loan) is a non-QM loan designed specifically for real estate investors. These loans are approved based on the income generated by the property—not your personal income, W-2s, or tax returns.

• Focus: Property cash flow
  
• Commonly used for: BRRRR refinances, short-term rentals, rental acquisitions
  
• Ideal for: Self-employed investors, LLC owners, or those scaling fast
  

✅ Key Benefit:

No personal income verification required.

What Is a Conventional Loan?

A conventional loan is a mortgage backed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac guidelines. These are your standard 30-year fixed loans that underwrite based on your personal credit, income, and debt-to-income (DTI) ratio.

• Focus: Borrower income and creditworthiness
  
• Commonly used for: Primary residences, second homes, and small rental portfolios
  
• Ideal for: W-2 employees or first-time investors
  

✅ Key Benefit:

Lower interest rates and closing costs—if you qualify.

DSCR vs. Conventional Loans: Side-by-Side Comparison

When to Use a DSCR Loan

DSCR loans are best when you:

• Don’t want to provide tax returns or personal income docs
  
• Operate under an LLC or entity
  
• Are scaling fast and have more than 10 properties
  
• Are refinancing a BRRRR or short-term rental
  
• Need faster closing with fewer requirements
  

Example:

You’re self-employed and own a duplex generating $3,200/month. Your DSCR is 1.35, but your taxable income is low. A DSCR lender qualifies you based on the property—not your personal income—and closes in 3 weeks.

When to Use a Conventional Loan

Conventional loans are best when you:

• Have steady W-2 income and a clean tax return
  
• Are buying your first few investment properties
  
• Want the lowest possible interest rate
  
• Plan to live in one unit (e.g. house hack)
  
• Don’t need LLC ownership or entity flexibility
  

Example:

You’re a salaried employee buying a 3rd rental. You have excellent credit, 25% down, and qualify easily with your DTI. A conventional loan gives you the best rate with no prepayment penalty.

Pros and Cons

✅ DSCR Loans

Pros:

• No income docs or DTI ratios
  
• Works with LLC ownership
  
• Great for STRs, BRRRR, and high-volume investors
  
• Unlimited property financing
  

Cons:

• Slightly higher interest rates
  
• Larger down payments
  
• Prepayment penalties apply
  
• Must meet minimum DSCR ratio (usually ≥1.20)
  

✅ Conventional Loans

Pros:

• Lower rates and fees
  
• No prepayment penalty
  
• Works for owner-occupied purchases
  
• Easier approval for W-2 earners
  

Cons:

• Requires income docs and full underwriting
  
• DTI limits can restrict your borrowing
  
• 10-property cap limits scalability
  
• Usually doesn’t work with LLC-owned properties
  

DSCR vs. Conventional: Which Loan Should You Choose?

Final Thoughts

Both DSCR and conventional loans have their place in a smart investment strategy. The key is matching the right loan type to your income profile, property goals, and ownership structure.

If you want speed, flexibility, and no income verification—DSCR loans are the clear winner.

If you’re a W-2 earner buying your first few properties—conventional might offer better pricing.

Either way, understanding the differences puts you in control of your financing and sets the foundation for a scalable, profitable portfolio.